Part composer, teacher, performer, musicologist, bureaucrat, and inventor seeger s ninetytwo year life touched many people and many areas of american music. The article titled on dissonant counterpoint was written by charles seeger and is found in volume 7, number 4 of the journal titled modern music on pages 2531. This project investigates how ruth crawfords applications of concepts from charles seeger s manual of dissonant counterpoint can inform nontonal jazz improvisation and composition. Was it possible to write dissonant music that nevertheless remained grounded in some sense of tonal center. In 1929 seeger revisited the method with ruth crawford at the insistence of cowell, who had taught it to her during the mid 1920s. Beyers use of phrase structure notation suggested by seeger in the treatise, with different numbers of measures per line, is especially interesting in the fourth movements. Born in mexico city to american parents, charles seeger 18861979 taught the first courses in musicology university of california, 19121919 and ethnomusicology the new school for social research, 1932 in the united states. December 14, 1886, mexico city february 7, 1979, bridgewater, connecticut was a musicologist, composer, and teacher. The greatest composer of dissonant counterpoint was johan sebastian bach, and seeger was understandably drawn to sacred harp hymns. This described a series of rules to establish how prominent harmonic dissonance might be achieved when creating 2 the text includes numbered references to a series of related links included by the editors.
Born in mexico city to american parents, charles seeger 18861979 taught the first courses in musicology university of california. The andante for strings is a transcription for string orchestra of the third movement of ruth crawford seeger s string quartet, composed in 1931. The curious afterlife of dissonant counterpoint jstor. In his essay, on dissonant counterpoint,3 seeger summarized both. Almost all modern courses on renaissance counterpoint, a mainstay of college music curricula, are indebted in some degree to this work by fux. This wideranging and personal collection provides a number of avenues for research in folk and modern music, musicology, and family history. This extension of consonance and dissonance to the domain of rhythm, apparently first suggested by charles seeger, and developed by maury yeston, has been recently. First species counterpoint must be all dissonances, establishing dissonance, rather than consonance, as the rule, and consonances are resolved. Crawford and seeger s collaboration between 1929 and 1931 culminated in a distinctive compositional approach called dissonant counterpoint that was founded on a dialectic between the traditions of western. Surviving sources that document the technique after its initial development include cowells unpublished notebook of exercises. The bibliographic citation includes all page numbers of the.
The early development of dissonant counterpoint 191417 involved the collaborative efforts of henry cowell and charles seeger at the university of california. Pescatello presents the first biography of charles seeger, who was a force in american music for most of the twentieth century. Meet three members of the seeger family charles seeger, ruth crawford seeger, and their daughter peggy seeger through their music, writings, and correspondence in the newly described seeger family collection. Ruth crawford came into her own as a composer in chicago. Much of beyers music, particularly that written between 1931 and 1939, reflects the aesthetics of the american ultramodernists, a circle which included ruth crawford seeger, charles seeger, henry cowell, dane rudhyar and carl ruggles.
The examples for the textonly pdf version of this item are available online at. He was the father of the american folk singers pete seeger, peggy seeger, and mike seeger. According to ethnomusicologist bruno nettl, seeger. Tempo melodies in the johanna beyer clarinet suites fourth. This collection of his essays, together with studies in musicology, 19351975 california, 1977, constitutes a major selected.
Charles seeger and twentyfirstcentury musicologies phaidra. Apr 04, 2011 text on dissonant counterpoint 1,3 developed around 1914. First species counterpoint must be all dissonances, establishing dissonance, rather than consonance, as the rule. Dissonant counterpoint grove music oxford music online.
He led the cologne opera for several years before moving to a teaching position at university of california berkeley. And joseph kerman provides the minimalistic counterpoint to mantle hoods concise. Tradition and experiment in the new musictenm, charles seeger s treatise on dissonant counterpoint, is the product of an intense period of collaboration between seeger and crawford from the summer of 1930 through september of 1931. Well what you see is what you get, in the sametitled piece as well as in gebrauchsmusik, which apparently pays tribute to hindemiths utility. Dissonant counterpoint ruth crawford string quartet 1931married to charles seeger and used some of his theoretical ideas like dissonant counterpoint at the request of varese, she provided and analysis of the 3rd and 4th movements of this string quartetiv. Asplund, who mentioned dissonant counterpoint in a sixteenthcentury counterpoint. He is best remembered for his formulation of dissonant counterpoint. Pdf charles seeger holds a truly unique place in the history of american music. Additionally, dissonant counterpoint, which is often eclipsed in historical surveys of twentiethcentury music by betterknown compositional techniques such as arnold schoenbergs twelvetone.
While tenm contains extended instructions in seegers theory of. Developing approaches to jazz composition and improvisation. In understanding charles seeger, pioneer in american musicology, ed. By using characteristically unusual voicing of instruments and dissonating the dynamics in the third movement of her quartet, crawford was able to achieve this shimmering effect. Tempo melodies in the johanna beyer clarinet suites. Mark nelson, in pursuit of charles seeger s heterophonic ideal. Dissonant counterpoint is the theory formulated by charles seeger, consisting of a reversal of the rules of traditional counterpoint, establishing dissonance, rather than consonance, as the rule. Find the latest tracks, albums, and images from charles seeger.
Seeger had developed in the 191osfor henry cowell who studied with him at berkeleya technique for writing dissonant counterpoint which was supposed to guarantee a consistent and strict use of dissonances based on the reversal of the old. Yes, according to her mentor, the composertheorist most responsible for dissonant counterpoint as a distinctive practice charles seeger 18861979, whom she later married. Oct 24, 2011 the dynamics of dissonance in seeger s treatise and crawfords quartet. Charles seeger, on dissonant counterpoint modern music 74 1930. Charles seeger taught dissonant counterpoint in 1916 hindemith in 1928. Studies in musicology ii, 19291979, charles seeger. American music, cowell reported that seeger had written studies in single, unac companied melody and in twoline dissonant counterpoint.
Also, you may be referring to charles seeger s concept of dissonant counterpoint, in which case you can refer to his original article on the subject. Metric and hypermetric dissonance in the menuetto of mozarts. Many of his pieces are dedicated to other composers, and poetically reimagine their ideas. Seeger left berkeley in 1918 and abandoned his work with dissonant counterpoint. Sep 01, 2006 compositional forms, harmony, and counterpoint 18. Charles ivesieach considered the other the worldis secondbest composeriand with charles seeger, whose theory of dissonant counterpoint exerted. Dissonant counterpoint, henry cowell, and the network of ultra. These are the chicago symphony orchestras first performances of crawford seeger s andante for strings. He was the father of the american folk singers pete seeger 19192014, peggy seeger b. There isnt a uniform system for dissonant counterpoint, but many composers attempt to forge their own way. During the late 1910s and throughout the 1920s, however, cowell continued to work on the technique and disseminated it to other composers. Cowell had weekly meetings with seeger to discuss new ideas in music. Three palindromic works by ruth crawford, the musical quarterly 72 1986. Many of beyers works are exemplary of dissonant counterpoint, a theoretical compositional system developed by charles seeger and cowell and.
He became known as one of the leading proponents of a style invented by musicologistcomposer charles seeger 18861979, who had been one of cowells mentors, known as dissonant counterpoint, an idiom in which the traditional rules of counterpoint were reversed to produce maximum dissonance rather than consonance. The pioneering modernist who wrote an audacious string. Dissonant counterpoint, a compositional approach invented by composer charles. It was in new york, and during this short period of time, that ruth crawford seeger composed the works she is most. Provided to youtube by the orchard enterprisesdissonant counterpoint i sarah cahill johanna beyercrawford 9 preludes cahill. According to the ethnomusicologist bruno nettl, seeger played a unique and. He combines aspects of counterpoint and serial technique. Listen to music from charles seeger like john hardy 1940. According to ethnomusicologist bruno nettl, seeger played a unique an read more. The early development of dissonant counterpoint 191417 involved the collaborative efforts of henry cowell and charles seeger at the university of california, berkeley. December 14, 1886 february 7, 1979 was an american musicologist, composer, teacher, and folklorist. Metric and hypermetric dissonance in the menuetto of.
A distinguished composer, scholar, and teacher, his long career. He noted her interesting use of dissonance and preserial techniques, and encouraged her move to new york city to study with charles seeger, known for his methodology in dissonant counterpoint. Inventory of the charles seeger musical compositions and published research articles, 19081978 processed by the music library staff. You may find ernst kreneks book, studies in counterpoint interesting. The work of ruth crawford seeger, henry cowell, some ligeti, and others. Dissonant counterpoint was originally theorized by charles seeger as at first purely a schoolroom discipline, consisting of species counterpoint but with all the traditional rules reversed. He was equally important as a teacher, administrator, and international figure in every sphere of music. Inventory of the charles seeger musical compositions and published research articles, 19081978. Charles seeger taught dissonant counterpoint in 1916. However, beyer developed her own distinctive gestures and procedures that distinguished her music from that of her colleagues. He is known, among other reasons, for his formulation of dissonant counterpoint.
Musicology, dissonant counterpoint, and folk musicthe seeger familys lasting legacy july 24, 2020 by paul sommerfeld the following is a guest post from archivist anita m. Crawford and seeger s collaboration between 1929 and 1931 culminated in a distinctive compositional approach called dissonant counterpoint that was founded on a dialectic between the traditions of western concert music, and experimentation with various types of dissonance. Charles seeger, manual of dissonant counterpoint 25 p. Bach, d minor prelude from well tempered clavier wtc, book 1 5 n. Liner notes including writers name and info ucsc music. The first movement of ruth crawfords string quartet 193 1, in a celebration of words. He even specified distinct levels of rhythmic dissonance contained in the broader field of rhythmic harmony. Pdf charles seeger download full pdf download book. Jan 21, 2021 dissonant counterpoint was originally theorized by charles seeger as at first purely a schoolroom discipline, consisting of species counterpoint but with all the traditional rules reversed. In her post seeger writing career, crawford executed her ideas by adhering largely to the rules of charles seeger s dissonant counterpoint. The treatise is best understood not as a finished document, but as a glimpse into seeger and crawfords. Tenney, which models a melodic principle known as dissonant counterpoint. Before commencing composition lessons with charles seeger, cowell had written the tides of manaunaun in 1911.
680 1222 964 309 1047 1336 319 367 382 1197 58 620 25 1701 1319 981 1365 1505 413 1517 1245 295 1290 631 1341 104